We went for my birthday dinner. The local cheese plate snack with our flight of cider was delicious. My salmon dinner was cooked perfectly and my husband’s steak with fresh herbs was also delicious. When they heard it was my birthday, we were gifted a dessert ice cider. Yum! Our waitress, Danielle, was fantastic. They had my favorite wine: Dr Constantine Frank Gewurztraminer. The Irish folk singer was very talented. Amazing evening.

Danielle was our server, she was super attentive and served us promptly. We’ve been here before, as we visit my wife’s sister once a year. The cider is top notch and the food is awesome.

Had such a great experience at Seminary Hill Cidery! The food was absolutely delicious and beautifully prepared, and the Jess made the whole visit even better. She was attentive, friendly, and made us feel so welcomed from start to finish. The atmosphere was gorgeous and relaxing too. Definitely worth the visit — can’t wait to come back!

Upon arriving at the cidery, we were immediately hit with the overwhelming smell of manure, which unfortunately set the tone for the rest of the experience. My friend and I ordered a flight since we usually enjoy a wide variety of ciders, but we genuinely didn’t like any of the six we picked. Most tasted flat and oddly similar to one another, with none really standing out. We also ordered a few snacks from the very limited menu, which were okay at best. What really made the experience off-putting, though, was the atmosphere from the staff. I had to walk over to the bar to ask for an extra glass because they only brought one for the bottle of cider we ordered.. so imagine my shock when later a waitress walked up to our table, took my glass directly in front of me without saying anything, and walked away with it. The whole visit felt like we were interrupting the staff while they were getting ready for something else. Between that and people working on laptops around the space, the vibe felt more awkward than welcoming. The view is nice, though.

This is one of our favorite restaurants upstate, we always make sure to stop by. The view is breathtaking and the food and drinks are consistently delicious. Our server Jess was attentive and welcoming when we were here last, looking forward to our next visit!

Such a cool place! The atmosphere is rustic and elevated, and the staff is very kind and knowledgeable. Mark gave an excellent tour, and Danielle and Ally were absolutely fantastic servers. Would definitely recommend checking it out if you get the chance!

We recently got married here, and it was truly the perfect venue for our intimate wedding ceremony and reception. The space is absolutely beautiful, with a wonderful mix of indoor and outdoor areas that made the day feel both elegant and relaxed. The onsite wedding coordinator was exceptional—organized, attentive, and incredibly helpful—making the entire planning process feel seamless and stress-free. We also hosted our welcome party at the Callicoon Theater in town, which was a huge hit. The views were incredible, and our guests loved exploring the area and taking everything in. The food throughout the weekend was delicious, and we received so many compliments from our guests. We couldn’t have imagined a better setting for our wedding weekend and are so grateful for such a memorable experience.

Seminary Hill was the perfect venue for our wedding. Tara and her team were amazing - they were quick to respond to our questions and incredibly helpful throughout the planning process. The views from their outdoor ceremony space were absolutely stunning, and the indoor reception areas were beautifully decorated and spacious. Our friends and family cannot stop raving about the delicious food as well, which we 100% recommend getting the venison! The day was perfectly coordinated by their staff, and everything went off without a hitch. We also had friends and family stay during the weekend at the Boarding House and other houses through Seminary Hill. Ronni and her team were extremely quick to respond and take amazing care of the gorgeous rooms/houses. We are so grateful to Seminary Hill for helping to make our special day truly unforgettable!

First time dining here last night with my boyfriend and we were disappointed… It was 5:30pm and it was slow so you would think the staff would provide great service. The food took a little while and it wasn’t that warm. I got the steak and it was good but small portions for a $40 steak. The staff were making themselves drinks from the bar and sitting in the other room and we had to get up to go pay at the bar because no one came over to us with our bill. Beautiful place to dine in but staff need to be better.

I held my 40th birthday party here and I couldn’t have asked for a better experience! The food was amazing (I am still thinking about the fried chicken!) and the staff was lovely. Special shout out to Stacey who helped me plan a spectacular event from start to finish!!