Seminary Hill Lodgings – photo 2 of 8
Seminary Hill Lodgings – photo 3 of 8
Seminary Hill Lodgings – photo 4 of 8

+4

Seminary Hill Lodgings – photo 1 of 8

Rooms

  • Boarding House: Apartment 1 (ADA Accessible)

    Assorted Room

    Standard Room

  • Boarding House: Apartment 2

    Assorted Room

    Standard Room

  • Boarding House: Apartment 3

    Assorted Room

    Standard Room

  • Boarding House: Apartment 4

    Assorted Room

    Standard Room

  • Boarding House: Apartment 5

    Assorted Room

    Standard Room

  • Boarding House: Apartment 6

    Assorted Room

    Standard Room

  • Boarding House: Apartment 7 (ADA Accessible)

    Assorted Room

    Standard Room

  • Boarding House: Apartment 8

    Assorted Room

    Standard Room

Property Overview

Immerse yourself in the understated elegance of Seminary Hill Lodgings, a truly unique escape where history and refined design converge. Each thoughtfully appointed space offers a serene sanctuary, designed to evoke a sense of peaceful luxury and quiet sophistication. Discover a distinctive blend of comfort and timeless charm, ensuring a truly restorative and memorable stay.

  • Fully-equipped kitchenettes
  • Complimentary weekend breakfast
  • Free toiletries
  • Shared library lounge

Amenities

Activities

  • Library
  • Outdoor furniture

Food and drink

  • Breakfast available (surcharge)
  • Electric kettle
  • Kitchen/Kitchenette
  • Microwave
  • Oven
  • Restaurant
  • Stovetop
  • Toaster
  • Coffeemaker
  • Cookware, dishware, and utensils
  • Mini-fridge

Internet access in public areas

  • Free WiFi
  • Wifi Available

Parking

  • Free self parking

Property services

  • Accessible property
  • Carbon monoxide alarm
  • Coffee/tea in common areas
  • Dry cleaning/laundry services
  • Fire extinguisher
  • First aid kit
  • Non-smoking rooms available
  • Pets allowed with a fee
  • Pets allowed
  • Wheelchair accessible

Bathroom

  • Free toiletries
  • Hair dryer
  • Towels provided

Bedding and linens

  • Cribs available (fees may apply)
  • Linens provided

Features

  • Air conditioning
  • Heating
  • Smoke alarms in rooms

Policies & key facts

Check-in
Check-out
Parking
IncludedFree self parking
Pets
AllowedPets allowed with a fee
Smoking
Non-smoking rooms available
Accessibility
Accessible property · Wheelchair accessible

Reviews

4.6

361

Reviews

Seminary Hill Lodgings receives mixed reviews, with many praising the stunning views and beautiful ambiance, particularly for events and weddings. However, recent feedback indicates significant service issues, including slow or inattentive waitstaff, inconsistent food quality, and operational problems like neglected drink orders. The property’s beauty and certain food and drink items are consistently highlighted, but persistent problems threaten the overall guest experience.

  • Stunning views
  • Beautiful ambiance
  • Excellent service (occasionally)
  • Delicious ciders
  • Beautiful setting for events
Cleanliness
4.5 out of 5
Location
5 out of 5
Value
3.5 out of 5
Service
2.5 out of 5
Amenities
4 out of 5
  1. Octavius Calloway

    Rated 1 out of 5

    This was by far the worst experience and service I have ever had at a restaurant. In the 3 HOURS we spent in this place we saw 2 servers and the host crying. It took literally 2 1/2 hours for our cheese plate, and meat plates to come out. Which makes no sense because you don't make the cheese or cook the prosciutto on site. We had to ask multiple times for refills on our water before it finally came. It was like none of them worked or visited a restaurant before. This place is horrendous. The only upside is the view. I can't believe they have such a high rating, this was by far the worst run restaurant I have been to. They need Gordon Ramsay to come fix whatever issues they're dealing with in this clown show, or sell to someone with experience and sense. After reading the other 1 star reviews I'm realizing my experience is one that most POC have here, which is extremely sad. In the replies they insist this isn't "who they are" but if all the 1 star reviews are mentioning the same problems maybe it indeed is who you are.

  2. Matt Ide

    Rated 4 out of 5

    Pulled up in a snow squall last November on our way home from the Catskills and although our romantic birthday getaway weekend was coming to a close, this was a cool symbol of the season to come. We didn't have long but the moment called for a flight of ciders and charcuterie, perched high above the orchard beneath their vaulted cathedral ceilings. It's elegant yet rustic, if that's a thing, and we wish we had another few hours to spend soaking in the ambiance. I really liked the physical design of the menu, it was an inviting pamphlet that felt just right for our rugged mountainview journey. They had a wide variety of ciders that were pleasant to drink (none I tried were overly sweet or effervescent) and their snacks and regular menu items looked thoughtfully arranged and sounded delicious.

  3. Jaycie Hutnick

    Rated 5 out of 5

    Tara (event coordinator) and her team were absolutely phenomenal when it came to the experience we had for a friend's wedding here! Everything from the service to the flow of events to the cleanliness kept was incredibly impressive. It takes a special skill set to manufacture perfection without anyone else realizing you're doing anything. This team achieved our friends' vision to a "T" while remaining relatively invisible. They are, without a doubt, some of the most customer-service oriented people I've ever had the pleasure of meeting. Thank you to everyone at Seminary Hill for such a beautiful and unforgettable experience!

  4. Ayon Ibrahim

    Rated 3 out of 5

    Food: everything was pretty good but with (sometimes strange) caveats. The salmon was good but the fennel was tough and nearly inedible. Cured salmon belly was underwhelming but ok. Duck was very tasty but my knife was dull. Burger was way too plain. The chicken skins, though...no complaints there, absolutely delicious. Most of drinks we tried were pretty good, nothing spectacular. Service: our waitress was an older woman who seemed to be...trying her best, but her best wasn't particularly good. She forgot drinks multiple times, put down the wrong food in front of people a few times, and overall gave the vibe that we were bothering her, or stressing her out, or something. It made us feel like we just needed to get out of there. Location: stunning vista, great outdoor space with games for the kids, totally lives up to the hype. Overall: wouldn't come back or recommend, unfortunately, unless you were a very small party that won't "overwhelm" the waitstaff.

  5. Rudis Lens

    Rated 5 out of 5

    My family and I came here on the Fourth of July, and we had a wonderful experience. The staff was very accommodating, and the views were absolutely spectacular. The food was delicious, especially the steak. Our server, Jessica, was amazing. She was always smiling, attentive, and made us feel so welcomed. We had a fantastic time and would definitely come back!

  6. hailey sheehan

    Rated 5 out of 5

    We had a wonderful experience thanks to our server. she was friendly, attentive, and made sure everything was perfect from start to finish. Drinks were always refilled, our food came out promptly, and she checked on us just the right amount without being overbearing. her positive attitude and excellent customer service really made our meal enjoyable. It’s hard to find service this great, and we truly appreciated the effort she put into making our visit special. The cidery is so beautiful, we can’t wait to come back! our server, krystalynn, mentioned she was new to the team but she had phenomenal recommendations on both the cider and the food!

  7. Jess Houghtaling

    Rated 5 out of 5

    I came to new york to visit friends and family and we went to seminary hill for our pre wedding dinner to celebrate. I just want to say this place is absolutely beautiful. The food was phenomenal the views were incredible the drinks were carefully curated. My only complaint is my waitress - Julie I had ordered drinks and about 10 minutes later I went inside to check out the bar and the bartender asked if I wanted a drink but I mentioned I put my order in about 10 mins ago but she was confused because she never received our drink order. The sweet blonde bartender starts making the drinks and then mentions she will have our server send them out but by then shes already taking our food order… no time to enjoy our apps and drinks. Just straight to Entrées other than the wait for drinks and rush for food, everything was so great except I never saw our server again. she greeted and served tables around me and every time I tried to get her attention she blatantly ignored our table. finally after an hour had passed (after we got food and drinks) and all of our glasses and plates were empty (waiting to order another round of drinks) we went and sat at the bar and were served immediately. another 25 minutes go by and she walks behind the bar and tells the bartender she should transfer the check. i look around and there’s 6 tickets with drinks made and ready to go to tables that are just sittttting there. mind you i haven’t heard a word from my server in an hour and a half & even after she told the bartender to transfer the check she still didn’t say a word to us so i can’t imagine how the other tables felt waiting for their now diluted drinks I’ve worked in service for 11 years now & thought i’ve seen it all but the service was something i’ve never experienced and I think seminary hill would benefit greatly by simply hiring a more attentive and professional Sever for this fine establishment

  8. Cathy Wilcox

    Rated 5 out of 5

    We went for my birthday dinner. The local cheese plate snack with our flight of cider was delicious. My salmon dinner was cooked perfectly and my husband’s steak with fresh herbs was also delicious. When they heard it was my birthday, we were gifted a dessert ice cider. Yum! Our waitress, Danielle, was fantastic. They had my favorite wine: Dr Constantine Frank Gewurztraminer. The Irish folk singer was very talented. Amazing evening.

  9. Paul Christiano

    Rated 5 out of 5

    Danielle was our server, she was super attentive and served us promptly. We’ve been here before, as we visit my wife’s sister once a year. The cider is top notch and the food is awesome.

  10. Kristen Yanow

    Rated 5 out of 5

    Had such a great experience at Seminary Hill Cidery! The food was absolutely delicious and beautifully prepared, and the Jess made the whole visit even better. She was attentive, friendly, and made us feel so welcomed from start to finish. The atmosphere was gorgeous and relaxing too. Definitely worth the visit — can’t wait to come back!

Map

Callicoon

Property Address
8 Hospital Road
Callicoon
Property Contact
845-887-4056
Powered byRipe